Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Final Blog Assignment :(
What conditions must be present before we can say a person is truly happy? Which of these conditions are most important? What is the best expression of the relationship between ethics and happiness? In essence, how can I identify if a person is truly happy and which of these conditions are most valuable and ethical?
(2) Conceptual Clarifications:
Happy in the Webster’s Dictionary is defined as having, showing, or causing a feeling of great pleasure, contentment, joy, etc.
(3) Answer:
Some of the conditions that are seen in a person that is truly happy are a peaceful, joyful and content demeanor. People who are truly happy are happy because of an internal decision to be happy with their life regardless of their circumstances. Happiness is an internal quality and is not based on luck or external circumstances. Happiness is often confused with the outward expression shown when life is good or when you experience the thrill of a success or good fortune. Happiness is a choice, an outlook, an attitude, and according to Abraham Lincoln, “You are as happy as you make up your mind to be”.
Another condition typical of a truly happy person is an attitude of gratitude. They focus on the things they are thankful for instead of focusing on all the things they do not have. Things in this reference do not only relate to material or financial wealth. Studies show that happy people have equal amount of success and failure as unhappy people. The difference is that unhappy people think twice as long on their failures and unhappiness.
A third condition often seen in happy people is their ability to think about the needs of other people. They get out of their own head and find someone else that may be less fortunate. They give of themselves and the result is they find happiness in helping others.
In addition, happy people worry less. It is not that they do not have things that would warrant worry. They make a choice to focus on what they have control over and let go of what they have no control over. They have learned that worrying about tomorrow is a waste of energy and robs them of the peace and joy they could be experiencing today. Happy people have less regrets over the past. They can acknowledge and accept that they may have made a mistake or if given the chance to do it over again, would do it different. However, happy people choose to let go of the past and make decisions today for a better tomorrow. Happy people have mastered the skill of living one day at a time and doing the best that they can do, JUST FOR TODAY. We have everything we need, just for today. When we get to tomorrow, then we will have the tools or wisdom to deal with tomorrow. Tomorrow is not here yet. That is why they call today, the present. It is our present in life to live each day, happy, joyous and free! This must be where the serenity prayer came from. God grant me the serenity to accept the things I can not change, the courage to change the things I can and the wisdom to know the difference.
Happiness and ethics go hand in hand. Studies show that people who work on their character and integrity are happier. It would make sense that if you have a clean conscience, live a moral life, are true to your values and yourself, you will experience more happiness, peace and contentment. Just remember that happiness is a choice and that you are as happy as you make up your mind to be. So, just for today, make a decision to be happy, focus on the positive, make a list of what you are grateful for, help someone less fortunate, don’t worry about tomorrow or regret the past, and enjoy your day to the fullest, one day at a time. I hope this blog will bring a little bit of happiness to you when you read it!
(4) Example:
A happy person could be down on their luck, without a job, have no money left in their bank account and instead of an attitude of lack, self pity, fear or worry, they chose to be thankful they are able to work. Their perspective on how they view their life circumstances is a positive outlook. Like the saying, “Is the glass half full or half empty”? Is it partly cloudy or partly sunny”? Perspective is everything. Perspective affects our attitude. How we think affects how we feel. How we feel affects how we act.
Life is full of ups and downs, good and bad. Whenever you are facing a difficult situation, just remember that “this too shall pass”. “When you worry, your face will frown and that will bring everybody down, so don’t worry, be happy”.
(5) Word Count:
Word Count 818
(6) Image:
Read more about “Positive Psychology” http://www.ppc.sas.upenn.edu/
Watch My Favorite Bobby McFerrin Utube Video, “Don’t Worry, Be Happy”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PE9ZXh0Fuwk
(7) References:
Ruggiero. (2008). Thinking Critically About Ethical Issues. McGraw Hill.
Positive Psychology Center. (2007).Seligman. University of Pennsylvania. 04/21/09.
http://www.ppc.sas.upenn.edu/
(8) Extra Credit:
Completed
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Blog Assignment #10
Michele Kuntz
Thurs. South Campus
Blog Assignment #10
STEP ONE:
THE DETAILS OF THE CASE(1) Choose one inquiry, from inquiries 1 - 28 (pages 114 - 117). Indicate which inquiry you chose, and then briefly explain it in your own words:
#11 An eight year old boy, Tom gives an expensive birthday gift to a poor boy after his parents told him to take special care of it.
(2) Stakeholders: Name each person, group, organization, etc., that has a stake in this outcome.
Tom (the eight year old)
Poor Boy
Parents
Poor Boy’s Parents, Siblings
(3) Are the details given sufficient? Why or why not?
I do not believe the details were sufficient. There are many questions to make an ethical judgment. The scenario does not tell us the consequence, if there was any. The parents may have modeled giving to those less fortunate.
(4) What additional questions does this inquiry raise?
How much did the toy cost? Did Tom ask his parents if he could give it away? What did the parents mean by “taking special care of the toy?” Was special care not losing it, not breaking it? Is giving to less fortunate a value Tom’s parents encouraged? What was the outcome, were his parents proud of Tom’s action or upset?
STEP TWO: THE RELEVANT CRITERIA
1. Obligations (aka "duties"): Obligations of Friendship, because his poor friend did not have any toys. Obligation of Beneficence, because Tom did a random act of kindness toward his poor friend. Obligation to his Parents, to do what he was told to do or to ask permission “if” he could give his toy away.
2. Moral Ideals (aka "virtues"): Virtue of Loving Kindness: “Love your neighbor as yourself“, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you”
Virtue of Compassion: Tom was empathetic toward the poor boy and gave him the toy because he was staring at his new toy.
Virtue of Courage: Tom gave away his new toy that his parents said to take special care of regardless of the consequences of his parents being upset with him.Virtue of Gratitude: Tom may have been grateful for all the toys he already has and therefore was generous by giving this one away.Virtue of Beneficence: Tom did a random act of kindness by giving the poor boy his toy with no expectation of return.Conflicting ideals: --consider the relative importance of each; determine which ideal represents the greater good (or the lesser evil). By giving his toy away, he may get in trouble with his parents, however, by showing loving kindness, courage, and beneficence these ideals may be of greater importance to Tom. He may have to ask forgiveness from his parents, repent or even reparation if his parents asked his to pay for the toy out of his piggy bank. It could also be a conflict with temperance, if he did not restrain his desire to give regardless of his parents instruction to take good care of his new toy.
3. Consequences (aka "outcomes" or "results"):
1)Tom may suffer consequences with his parents for giving his toy away without asking permission.
2) Tom’s parents may view it that Tom was not grateful for the new toy.
3) Tom’s parents may be upset because it was an expensive toy and they used all their savings. 4) Tom’s parents may be very proud of him for his compassion, generosity, and sacrifice he made by giving his new toy away.
5) Tom may regret his impulsive decision and may not get another toy like this one.
6) Tom’s parents may be so proud of his action that they buy him another one just like it.
STEP THREE: POSSIBLE COURSES OF ACTION
Alternative #1: Tom could have called his parents and asked permission before he gave his toy away.
Alternative #2: Tom could have saved his money and purchased the poor boy a different toy at a different time.
Alternative #3: Tom could have given the boy some of his other toys instead of the new birthday present.
STEP FOUR:
THE MOST ETHICAL ACTION Examine the action taken or proposed and decide whether it achieves the greater good (the most widespread "respect for persons")...if it does not, choose one that will, from your alternatives. Where the choice of actions is such that no good can be achieved, choose the action that will result in the lesser evil.
Alternative #1 provides the greater good for all. Tom asking permission before giving his toy away would have been respecting his obligation to his parents. They could have said yes, and then there would be no bad consequences. Or if his parents responded with no, he could have saved his money and bought the little boy a toy. The book references three requirements which is referred to as the “principle of the double effect.” These three conditions are when the good consequences outweigh, can not be separated from or not intended the bad consequences. The reasoning is stated in the book,“Is it justifiable to perform an act that is not in itself evil but produces mixed consequences, some of them beneficial and others harmful?”(page 121)
SELF EVALUATION
1. In your own words, describe something new that you learned from this week’s assigned reading material and guidance.
The most significant thing I learned was to consider the details of a case, a situation, or dilemma before I form my moral or ethical conclusion. Think about the consequences and choose the better of two evils or achieve the greater good. It makes me think about the situation without reacting with an immediate conclusion or judgment. I have a choice on how I want to respond to an event or situation.
2. In your own words, describe in detail some insight you gained, about the material, from one of your classmates' blogs this week.
Blog posted by andeps-ethicsblog at andeps-ethicsblog1
1. In your own words, describe something new that you learned from this week’s assigned reading material and guidance.“The explanation of courage was meaningful to me. I guess I never really thought of it as having 3 dimensions. I was moved by the story about the little girl on the bus who befriended the other boy. I would not have thought about it being a conflict of ideals – I now realize that it was not exactly honest, but it was certainly the right thing to do.”
There were very few blogs posted to read. However, I also liked the example Paul referred to. It challenged my thinking, to think a little deeper about the case. I would value the ideal of Loving Kindness and Courage over Honesty. The conflict with honesty has an exception, when telling the truth would bring harm, damage, or hurt to the person we are being honest with. It takes courage to stand against peer pressure and be kind, compassionate, and empathetic to the unlovely.
3. Did you post a thoroughly completed post to your blog on time this week?
Yes, I completed the entire assignment and posted my blog on time this week.
4. Did you ALSO print this out, so you can bring it to class and earn total points? Yes, I printed this out and will bring it to class tomorrow! ON TIME!
5. Of 25 points total, my efforts this week deserve:
My effort on this assignment earned the 25 points because I have read, analyzed, considered the case in light of the guidelines between obligations, moral ideals, consequences and dilemmas. This assignment was helpful in gaining a better understanding of who, what, when, why, and how of analyzing ethical issues. I considered what I read before I answered the questions and I referred back to my book to make sure I responded with understanding. I got the most out of this assignment, maybe because it is finally sinking in. Thanks!
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
Blog Assignment #9
In this section, we're going to return for a moment to Chapter 7, to the section that discusses errors that are common in the analysis of moral issues (p. 89). Briefly explain each of the following errors in your own words, as if you were explaining the concept to a friend who had never taken this class (consider who, what, when, where, why, how, when); and then give an example of each one, preferably from your own past experience.
Unwarranted Assumptions:
Unwarranted assumptions is when you jump to a conclusion before you know the details. You assume and read between the lines of things that may not be true.
JUDGMENT: The VW Service Department Was Overcharging me for Repairs to my car
P: The mechanics work on commission and therefore found more things to charge me for
P: The neighborhood mechanic only charged me $400 instead of $3500
P: The neighborhood mechanic said the other repairs were not necessary
CONCLUSION (Unwarranted Assumption): Dealerships are unfair and are dishonest
Oversimplification:
Oversimplification is when we minimize or omit important facts of a case or situation. As a result of oversimplifying, it does not give the full picture or can distort the outcome. When dealing with an embarrassing family matter or personal situation, it is often easy to oversimplify as a coping mechanism. Minimizing the facts.
Hasty Conclusions:
I am GUILTY! Hasty conclusions is when we jump to a judgement without having all the facts. Reacting instead of responding. The fear of a consequence can contribute to a quick judgment without fully understanding the situation or case. I like the example of separate self into two people. The first person is the idea producer and the second person is the idea evaluator. And the IF... THEN thought process. This helps you to consider all the criteria and consider the possible outcomes before jumping to a hasty conclusion.
JUDGMENT: My son will go to jail
P: He smelled of beer
P: He was going to drive
P: He had a beer with dinner
CONCLUSION (Hasty Conclusion): He will get a DUI if he drives
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO
1. What do we do in situations where there is more than a single obligation?
Try to fulfill both obligations if possible. Consider which one is most important. Make the best of both obligations and try to make up to the obligation we had to break in order to keep the other. Use the "IF....THEN" to evaluate the obligation.
2. How can we reconcile conflicting obligations?
Ask the "IF...THEN" question to think through the consequences and evaluate which one holds a higher priority. Try to resolve by managing both obligations and if not possible and one obligation must be broken, try to make it up. I try to be careful to not over commit or avoid having conflicting obligations. However, when faced with it, I evaluate carefully the situation and ask myself, what can I live with if I break this obligation or the other. I follow my heart, my conscience, my value system and then try to redeem my broken obligation in another way.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART THREE
1. In a nutshell, what is the most important thing, for you, that you learned from this assignment?
I learned that I have more obligations than I realized. There are many more conflicting obligations than I realized in my life. To use the IF.... THEN question, it helps me to evaluate the outcome of the obligations and decisions I have to make. I also learned to give greater consideration to the details of a case and to think of the impact and outcome before making a judgement.
2. How will you apply what you learned through this assignment to your everyday life?
LISTEN, LISTEN, LISTEN. Listen more before I speak. Consider all the details before I jump to a conclusion. Again, using the IF... THEN will really help me to think before I speak!
3. What grade do you believe your efforts regarding this assignment deserve? Justify your answer. This is a revised version. My first blog was way longer and even though I spent more time, I did not really understand. I had to revise to be more applicable to the questions. Therefore, because I went back and completed a second time, hopefully, this time with better answers, I earned the 25 points.
Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Blog Assignment #6
Blog Assignment #6
--------------------------------------------------------------
PART ONE
QUESTION #1: If an action that is praised in one culture may be condemned in another, would it be correct to say that all moral values are relative to the culture they are found in?
ANSWER: I agree that moral values are relative to the culture they are associated with. Multiculturalism is the different values and morals of different cultures. However, moral values may differ between cultures, however, there is still right and wrong. To judge a man for behaving in a way that would be immoral and wrong in our culture would not be fair. We may not understand his position if we have never walked in his shoes, but right and wrong can be judged. It would be safe to say that our values and morals based on our experiences, influences from society and family of origin. Our environment, nature and nurture plays a significant role in our value system. This issue is a two edged sword. The norm for a culture or subculture to behave in an immoral way may be acceptable in that environment, but it does not justify an immoral act. There are universal values such as murder. Just because a culture or subculture practices human sacrifice or cannibalism, it is still morally wrong. They may not realize it is wrong, based on their conscience. Ignorance of right and wrong does not justify the action. There may not be consequences in their culture to commit immoral acts but it does not mean there may not be consequences in an after life. If there is a higher power, they may stand accountable.
Conclusion: Cultural differences do not justify acts of violence against another human being because:
P: Inflicting pain on another individual does not justify the behavior just because it is a cultural practice.
P: Just because you do not know any better, does not make it right to violate another human
P: They would not like to be the recipient of the torturous acts if the immoral or torture was done against them.
P: Pain is pain is pain. Any living thing does not enjoy pain.
C: Therefore, it is correct to say that all moral values are relative to the culture they are found in (or therefore it is NOT correct to say…)
QUESTION #2: Is it a mark of ignorance to pass judgments on other cultures or to claim that one culture is better than another?
ANSWER : I do not believe it is a sign of ignorance to pass judgement on other immoral actions by other cultures. It may be ritualistic but it does not escape judgement. Here on earth or the after life. I believe we must remain true to our self and not compromise our value system to accommodate other cultures. It is okay to maintain a standard, universal standard of right and wrong, moral and immoral when it comes to violating another human or living thing. Our judgements are based on a standard whether from the Bible, Koran, Karma or whatever spiritual or human dignity that we believe in. Judgement is an opinion of right and wrong, however, does not necessarily mean we are imposing punishment based on our opinion. There may be graces or exceptions to the rule. As an example, a young girl murders her father is not morally, legally or spiritually acceptable. However, given the circumstances that he was raping her for years and she reacted in self defense.
C: Therefore it is NOT a mark of ignorance to pass because:
P: To compromise a moral value, universal standard is to water down and minimize inappropriate behavior
P: The frequency of committing immoral behavior will sear the conscience to recognize right from wrong.
P: They may commit an immoral act today and feel justified, however, how do we know if it will not torture their conscience tomorrow.
P: Maintaining a standard of right and wrong and judging immoral behavior is a mark of staying true to one's own self.
PART TWO
Page 64, 12b The missionary's action is justifiable based on her mission to reach, teach, educate a primitive tribe that their superstition of cutting off an offender's hand is unnecessary suffering of a human being. There may be other appropriate consequences without undue human suffering. Her teaching may help them to put them self in the shoes of the offender and help them to think about how they would feel if it were them. The missionaries mission is to bring a form of faith and alternative perspectives on their primitive culture. The missionary is there to teach that a loving God will provide and by trusting in a good God that loves them versus a god that rejoices in the torture of humans does not inspire people to love a mean god. The missionary is fulfilling her purpose by presenting alternatives to teach life changing values.
Conclusion: The missionary's actions are justifiable because:
P: A missionary's role is to reach people and bring peace and freedom to the primitive tribe
P: The missionary has a responsibility to follow her convictions and share the values of human life and how to avoid merciless torture.
P: If the primitive tribe never hears alternatives, how will they learn a more civil response to how they treat human beings
P: It gives the tribe the opportunity of choice once they hear an alternative way to respond
P: Given the opportunity and new way of thinking, they may see a more loving God or reason to believe there is a way to respond without human torture.
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Blog Response to TJR-Ethics - Snowboarder Dilema
In response to your snow boarding incident. Arguable Issue: Whether or not the parents of the child should apologize to the injured snowboarder. Conclusion: Definitely the parents of the child should apologize to the injured snowboarder because:
1) The parents are responsible for the child's action (whether intentional or accidental).
2) The parents should teach the child to apologize when someone is injured by their actions
3) The parents need to teach their child ski slope courtesy
4) If the parents do not teach their child the rules of the slopes, good luck with the rules on the road.
Even though I am arguing on behalf of the injured skier, I understand both sides. Being a skier and back when my son was a young skier, he was oblivious, often out of control, heading straight down the hill, with no poles and on a mission! I empathize with both sides, however, I side with the parents primarily because the child was not injured and the snowboarder was.
Thanks for the food for thought! :)
Blog Assignment #5
"Evil R US: 1 in every 4 people have no conscience".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQjdaEUcTAE
2. Cite the resource--either link to it and/or clearly list it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQjdaEUcTAE
3. Explain how and why it relates to our readings. Be specific; note which passages from our text most relate & why.
The first video is titled: "Evil R US: 1 in every 4 people have no conscience". Is it a sign of the times influenced by social conditioning or natural endowment? Have we become so self absorbed that we can not respond to another human being in trouble. Late for work, following the crowd, or paralyzed in shock. Watching this video was very troubling. How can you walk by and not react to a life or death situation of a person or even an animal. I have reacted quicker to a dog that was hit by a car than these people did. Is this due to an innate, genetic sensitivity chip or is it a moral choice, hereditary or social conditioning? It is instinctive to help people or animals that are suffering. Is it a maternal instinct? Or is it imprinted on our brain sociologically and psychologically? Which brings me to my arguable issue. Whether or not a sociopath has a conscience? My conclusion is that a sociopath does not have a conscience because:
Premises:
1) A sociopath can commit terrible acts of violence toward people or animals and show no sign of shame or remorse
2) A sociopath's moral sense or intuition does not distinguish between right and wrong
3) A sociopath is deceived by believing their distorted justification for their wrong doing.
4) A sociopath is unable to pass the three brief tests below labeled Test 1, Test 2 & Test 3 which will only take a few minutes to take all three.
5) A sociopath will not post their test results and title their blog, "Sociopath Test Results".
4. In a separate paragraph, tell me how many points you believe your efforts deserve--in argument form! (Karla, if you read this, how do I remove the extra lines in between my Arguable Issue & lines 2,3,4?) Formatting errors bug me!
Arguable issue: whether or not this post deserves 25 points (the maximum points)
Conclusion: this post deserves 25 points
Premises: this post deserves 25 points because:
(1) I learned how to access UTube for the first time and to attach my video choices to my blog.
(2) I completed my reading assignment and gave a lot of thought and consideration to the material.
(3) I searched for the right video to post and created an arguable issue for my theory regarding a sociopath and found tests to post.
(4) I completed my blog before the deadline of 11:59 pm on Wednesday!
"Evil R US: 1 in every 4 people have no conscience".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQjdaEUcTAE
Test 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgZGuasi1q0
Test 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDvg0S0ftK8
Test 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IO1HVH9IvaU
Wednesday, January 28, 2009
Blog Assignment #4
ASSIGNMENT PART ONE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Relationship between Law & Ethics
1. Paragraph: explain in your own words what the relationship is between laws and ethics.
Laws and ethics are not necessarily the same, however, they are interdependent upon each other. Laws are external guidelines, boundaries, or rules that govern our society and set by lawmakers who decide what is right or wrong legally. Ethics are the internal guidelines that define our morality. What is right or wrong, good or bad, and based on how an individual believes or what is socially acceptable. Both are judged by being right or wrong, however, laws can be enforced but ethics can not be enforced unless it violates the law. Laws have external consequences, whereas, ethics may or may not suffer internal consequences such as guilt or shame depending on the value system of the individual. Without ethics it is not possible to have laws. Ethics on the other hand is subjective to the circumstances and the lack thereof does not violate the laws of the land.
2. Paragraph & Link: Find one online resources related to this topic—not Wikipedia. Explain in a brief paragraph what you learned about this topic through the resource you found; include the link at the end of your paragraph.
It appears that the issue of law and ethics has been a topic of debate for sometime. One of the great debates occurred in 1958 at Harvard Law Review between H.L.A. Hart (an Oxford Professor) and Lon Fuller (Harvard Law School). Fuller's position was that “law was not a neutral concept, but that it already embodied an inner morality of its own". Hart stated, "nothing called law can be wicked or unjust". This historical debate is being celebrated almost fifty years later at New York University Law School and the NYU Law Review on February 1-2, 2009. Ethics, morality and the law overlap and influence each other. Without ethics, we would not have laws and without laws morality or the lack thereof would become non existent.
http://www.law.nyu.edu/conferences/hartfuller/index.htm
3. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not we need ethics, given that we already have laws.
Conclusion: (FOR) We need ethics, given that we already have laws.
Premises: We need ethics, given that we already have laws because:
(1) We need ethics to maintain a conscience and morality.
(2) We need ethics to consider others & maintain "The Golden Rule"
(3) We need ethics to uphold law, order, and safety in our society
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Role of the Majority View
1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what a Majority View is.
The majority view is based on statistical results. The greatest number in a group that holds an opinion or view of what is right or wrong. The majority view may not have all the information to make an adequate judgement. Without given all the details of a situation, it would be difficult to trust the opinion of the majority's view, therefore, it may not be a trustworthy source. We must use critical thinking to consider the circumstances that may influence our thinking based on the known and the unknown.
2. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not the Majority View is a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.
Conclusion: (AGAINST) The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making
Premises: The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making because:
(1) The majority view may not have all the information to form a conclusion
(2) The majority view could falsely accuse or judge based on limited information
(3) The majority view can lead in the wrong direction
The Role of Feelings
1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what feelings are.
Feelings are subjective and can not be relied upon for determining morality or decisions. Feelings can include desires and or preferences and can change based on circumstances. If everyone acted upon their feelings, desires or preferences, we would live in a world without boundaries. Feelings are fickle and can lead us down the wrong path. I may have strong feelings to act in a certain manner to escape the pain of the circumstance I am facing. However, logic and common sense should be balanced with feelings. Many factors can influence feelings, surroundings, health, external and internal forces. Therefore, similar to the majority view, feelings require critical thinking skills to dissect.
2. Argument:
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not our feelings are a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.
Conclusion: (Against) Feelings are not a reliable basis for ethical decision making.
Premises: Feelings are not a basis for ethical decision making because:
(1) Feelings can change and therefore are not a reliable source for decision making.
(2) Feelings are based on emotion and are not logical about decision making
(3) Feelings are influenced by external factors and can be deceiving in decision making.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART THREE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ability to express yourself in your own words is essential in this class. Did you put everything in your own words this time?
Yes, I wrote from my heart and expressed myself in my own words.
What was easiest / hardest about this assignment?
The easiest part of this assignment was researching the relationship between ethics and law. I found it interesting and it made me aware of the dilemma in this debatable issue. The hardest part of this assignment for me is structuring the arguments. I think I am over thinking on how to word my premises. I understand the format but am not satisfied with what I have written. I may revisit my answers and revise before you grade this.
How will you apply what you learned through this assignment to your everyday life?This assignment has influenced me in how I think about things. I tend to form my opinion quickly and this assignment has helped me to use critical thinking skills. To think outside the box and not be so quick to form my opinion. It also reinforces my value of being true to myself. When considering the majority view, be open minded, however, remain true to my values even if I stand alone. I will apply this to my decision making, to how I respond to my son, and to challenge my own thoughts and ideas.
How well do you think you did on this assignment? Explain.I have done well on this assignment because I spent the time reading, pondering, and re-reading the assignment before I answered the questions. I did not just answer the questions but gave thoughtful consideration in everything that I wrote. I enjoyed the assignment and have a better understanding of moral relativism, ethics, law and religion. I found the chapter on majority views and feelings very interesting and enjoyed contemplating the inquiries at the end of each chapter.
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Blog Assignment #3
According to the book, to give an argument means to present why you believe or have an opinion by demonstrating, proving and defending how you have come to your belief. Reasons are supported by evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are defined as a way to evaluate and defend with supporting evidence an opinion, belief, or theory. Arguments are a testimony of your views with an attempt persuade and support with evidence how you have come to your conclusion.
What are the reasons Weston gives in support of his claim, “arguments are essential”?
Weston states that arguments are essential to determine which idea has a better platform and can be supported with evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are a way to illustrate or prove my position and how I have supported my belief, opinion, theory. How can I be convincing to present my ideas without knowing how I have arrived at my opinion? There must be reasons to support my conclusions. By supporting my reasons and conclusions in a clear and concise format, it will make my presentation more convincing and will help others to form a conclusion the same way I have formed my conclusion.
3. Explain why many students tend to “write an essay, but not an argument”.
Weston explains the reason students write an essay but not an argument is because they do not understand how to support their belief or views on an issue. In order to write an argumentative essay, you must not only state your reasons for your view but the evidence to support your conclusion. One way Weston suggests preparing for an argumentative essay is to evaluate both sides. By evaluating both sides, you are more prepared to defend your conclusions and support how you have formed your opinion and views.
4. Construct two short arguments (one "for" and one "against") as modeled in the Week 3 Assignment section in Blackboard. Put each one in "elements form".
Argument AGAINST an Adoptee Locating Birth Parent(s)
Arguable issue: Whether or not an Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s)
Conclusion: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s).
Premises: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s) because:
1) Doing so will violate the privacy of the birth parent(s) and their new family
2) Doing so will be a disappointment and will hurt the adoptee emotionally
3) Doing so will hurt their adopted family
Argument FOR an Adoptee to locate Birth Parent(s)
Conclusion: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s)
Premises: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s) because:
1) Doing so will help satisfy the birth parent(s) guilt
2) Doing so will help the adoptee know their medical history and gain understanding why they were placed for adoption.
3) Doing so will open the door to have a relationship with their birth parent(s) and siblings
5. Review the seven rules in chapter one. Briefly discuss how your argument demonstrates that each rule was applied, in the construction of your arguments above.
1) Distinguish Premises and Conclusion. The purpose of my argument is to support the benefits of finding your birth parents. 2) Present your ideas in a natural order. I started out with my conclusion and then supported my conclusion with my premises. Using my own personal experience as well as the opinions of the opposing side. 3) Start from reliable premises. I used premises from my own experience and from the experience of other adoptees finding their birth parents. 4) Be concrete and concise. I have avoided abstract, vague and general terms. I tried to keep it simple and to the point. 5) Avoid loaded language. I have tried to be objective on both sides in my wording. I have not used words that would discriminate toward either side even though I have a strong opinion for or against. Which one do you think it is? 6) Use consistent terms. I have tried to stay with the effects on the birth parents, the adoptee and the adopted family. 7) Stick to one meaning for each term. I have stayed with one meaning for each term. I have avoided the classical fallacy of equivocation.
6. Review the three rules in the appendix named, “Definitions”. In your own words, discuss how you took these rules into consideration as you constructed your arguments.First clearly identify the meaning of your words. Using a dictionary can not be your only source to define and clearly state your terms. Avoid vague, mixed message words and do not minimize the context to the point of losing the meaning . Be as specific as possible so that the words are understandable and not easily misconstrued. Make sure both parties are discussing the same thing. Defining the word alone does not defend the argument. When the understanding of term is contested, there are three steps to clarify. 1) Include all things that fit, 2) exclude all things that do not fit, and 3) draw a line somewhere in between and explain why.
I reviewed the appendix of definitions before I constructed my arguments. I tried to be as clear and concise to state my terms. I tried to listen to how others would hear it. I tried to differentiate between an adopted vs. birth family.
7. Good posts demonstrate:
Sincere reflection, effort, and analysis
Answers that are substantial (at least one large paragraph each)
Consistent mention, citation, and integration of the assigned readings. How many points do you honestly feel your post this week deserves? Justify your answer.
If points are earned on effort, I earned 25. However, I am not sure I completely understand everything. I guess that is why they call it learning! I definitely read, reflected and answered the questions to the best of my ability in my own words. In addition to reading the material, I referred back to the books as I was writing. I kept notes of everything I read to review and refresh and hopefully gain a greater understanding to master the material. And last but not least, I got it posted before 11:59!
Blog Assignment #2
The questions were not difficult to answer, however, I had to resist my instinctive answer and contemplate what I might do if I were in a similar situation. My first response would be to avoid hurting anyone, even if the intention was to help someone else. As I carefully thought about the situation, I had additional questions before I could respond with a definitive answer. Without all the details available, I responded with my first impression. I can see that under certain circumstances I could have responded differently to each situation. In all of the scenarios, I believed there were alternative options that could potentially help one scenario without hurting someone in the process. Psychologically and emotionally the moral decision for me would be, to not intentionally hurt someone for any reason. Technically, there could be a situation where it would be the right or moral response to inflict harm on one person to save hundreds. An example of this would be the decision that was made on 911 when the passengers overtook the terrorists forcing a crash and their lives to avoid killing thousands. The test questions were overall consistent with the exception of one. The hide and seek game was a competition to win. Dropping a branch, (depending on how big of a branch) would be morally acceptable "IF" it would not injure the girl in the bush.
2. Should people always follow the law? Why or why not? When might one be justified in NOT following the law? Give examples.
My opinion about following the law is very rigid. "Follow the laws of the land". I believe the laws are set to protect us all. Laws are boundaries to serve and protect everyone. I may not always agree with the law but I will follow the law to the best of my ability. There are times that laws are broken without the intent to break the law. So there is the exclusion to my opinion based on intent. They say, ignorance of the law does not excuse the consequences, however, if you know it is wrong and you do it anyway, then I feel differently. In addition, I believe you reap what you sow. You may get away with not following the law, but eventually you will get caught. You can only run so many red lights without getting caught. Then again, it could just be my paranoid, guilt driven conscious. :) However, there would be situations that I could justify breaking the law. I can assume I would shoot someone if they were a threat to myself or my family. Then again, if I were in the situation, I am not sure what my instinct would do. Unless I actually experience it first hand, I may not be able to shoot someone. Another example of not following the law would be if I were abducted and the car jacker has a gun pointed at my head and told me to keep driving. I could see myself intentionally colliding with another vehicle to draw attention and hopefully escape from the bad guy! Another example would be if I were driving someone to the hospital with a life threatening condition. I would speed, run red lights and do whatever I could to get the passenger help. However, I would do my best to avoid hurting someone else in the process.
3. In your own words, explain what "social convention" means. Give examples.
Social convention is a spoken, unspoken, or socially acceptable behavior that the majority or society lives by. An example of a social convention could be a man giving up his seat for a woman. Another example would be to open the door for a woman or a handicapped person. A third example would be to not begin eating until everyone has been served. These would be considered "good manners". However, there are moral, religious, ethical, cultural and socially acceptable behaviors that may be different for different environments.
4. Should people always follow the conventions of their society? Why or why not? Give examples.
"Should" is an interesting word. Whether they should or should not could be different for different people. This could be influenced by age, culture, upbringing, etc. It would be nice if most followed the conventions of their society, however, there may be factors why a person may not follow social conventions. An example would be how we greet people. Growing up in an Italian family, it was normal to hug and kiss both sides of your face. For some, this type of greeting would be invasive and overstepping an individuals boundary. Social conventions can be a result of the environment you are raised in. Nature vs. Nurture creates an interesting concept. I was adopted and have learned behaviors (Nurture) and instinctive behaviors (Nature) that reflect both my birth family and my adopted family. I read a statistic, (that I can not quote from where) that there are just as many PhD that raised drug addicts as there are drug addicts that raised PhD. Therefore, do others follow social conventions or is their behavior an innate response.
5. Should people always follow their own principles? Why or why not? Give examples.
Yes, I do believe you should follow your convictions, principles, and values that you have defined for yourself. "To thine own self be true". However, principles and values can change or broaden as a result of life experiences. For example, after surviving a near death experience I thought, "if I am going to die, why not have fun today"? The first mistake was the "if". It is not if but when. However, when I became a mother, I no longer took risks that could leave my child motherless. So after my son's birth, I quit jumping off the Dames Point Bridge for fun. :) Just kidding about the bridge part. One last thought, if I do not follow my own principles, I get to live with the consequences of not being true to myself. I do what I believe is the right thing to do, however, I am not so rigid that I am not open to feedback for consideration. Even if they do say, you can not teach old dogs, new tricks.
6. Explain in your own words the difference between socially acceptable, legally acceptable, and morally acceptable.
Socially acceptable would be what the majority of society considers to be normal and acceptable behavior such as wearing a bikini to school! It may cause a few raised brows or strained necks! This would also depend on the society, culture, or environment you are in. What is socially acceptable to one may be totally inappropriate to another.
Legally acceptable would be anything within the statutes. An example would be regarding the concealed weapon's permit. You may only carry a loaded gun on your person if you obtain your concealed weapon's permit. There are certain places that you are not able to carry a gun, such as school or the post office. If you ever have to use your gun, you can not shoot to kill. That is not legally acceptable. You are only able to shoot to stop someone from committing a crime against you or your family. Can you tell I just took my concealed weapon's permit class?
Morally acceptable is a code of ethics or moral values that a society, environment, culture, religion or group lives by. It depends on the moral standards and circumstances of your environment. I would describe morally acceptable by biblical principles, such as the ten commandments. Thou shalt not commit adultery. However, it also says if you lust in your heart, you have committed adultery. Therefore, morally acceptable is an individual value system. There are exceptions to morally acceptable behavior. Some situations may provoke a response that would be deemed morally unacceptable, however, necessary to protect another individual from being hurt. I believe our conscious is a moral guide. If the conscious is ignored long enough, it will allow you to violate your own moral code. An example would be if you were to put a hot iron on your arm, it would burn the first time. However, if you continue with the same action, eventually scar tissue would form and you will not feel the pain when you put the hot iron on the same spot. Moral of the story, don't iron your clothes when you are wearing them.
7. Out of 25 points, how many points do you feel your work on this assignment deserves? Justify your answer.
I believe I deserve the 25 points for a couple. The number one reason, I have had to put in several hours trying to master this blog thing! I hate to admit that this may be my first generational disconnect! You could have been speaking a foreign language to me, it was that confusing to me. However, with hours and hours of persistence, I think I got it. I still have a way to go, but I am on my way. "It is not the destination but the journey" Fun! The second reason is because I have read my books and gave careful thought and consideration to each and every question. Now I will try to publish this BLOG! Hope it arrives safely!
Thursday, January 15, 2009
Blog Assignment #1
2. What are some of your deepest held values?
3. What are some main principles you try to live your life by?
6. How have your values and principles changed throughout your life so far?
7. Out of 25 points, how many points do you feel your work on this assignment deserves? Justify your a nswer.