Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Blog Response to TJR-Ethics - Snowboarder Dilema

I have been patiently waiting to hear how you handled the previous dilema. "Did you kiss her or not?"

In response to your snow boarding incident. Arguable Issue: Whether or not the parents of the child should apologize to the injured snowboarder. Conclusion: Definitely the parents of the child should apologize to the injured snowboarder because:
1) The parents are responsible for the child's action (whether intentional or accidental).
2) The parents should teach the child to apologize when someone is injured by their actions
3) The parents need to teach their child ski slope courtesy
4) If the parents do not teach their child the rules of the slopes, good luck with the rules on the road.

Even though I am arguing on behalf of the injured skier, I understand both sides. Being a skier and back when my son was a young skier, he was oblivious, often out of control, heading straight down the hill, with no poles and on a mission! I empathize with both sides, however, I side with the parents primarily because the child was not injured and the snowboarder was.

Thanks for the food for thought! :)

3 comments:

  1. Do you believe in miracles?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I ended up not kissing her because a lot of the issues you had posed were the same ones that I had running through my mind. If you have more questions on this one let me know I posted another lengthier reply on top of yours in my blog.

    At the end of your post I think you meant you empathize with the boarder not the parents, but I could be wrong. This was definitely a tough issue for me because I snowboard and I hate seeing little kids on the slopes especially the intermediate ones. I wasn't really sure where to go I mean I felt bad the boarder was injured but still felt for the parents and kid seeing as how he could have easily been injured as well. I do like most of your points on teaching the kid rules of things. At least you picked a side argued for or against it and stuck to it. I'll try to put some more as they come along.

    Thanks

    LonghornRunning

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes, that is what I meant to say. I sided with the boarder not the parents. I guess it was late and I forgot to review my response before posting. Thanks for the update.

    ReplyDelete