Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Blog Assignment #6
Blog Assignment #6
--------------------------------------------------------------
PART ONE
QUESTION #1: If an action that is praised in one culture may be condemned in another, would it be correct to say that all moral values are relative to the culture they are found in?
ANSWER: I agree that moral values are relative to the culture they are associated with. Multiculturalism is the different values and morals of different cultures. However, moral values may differ between cultures, however, there is still right and wrong. To judge a man for behaving in a way that would be immoral and wrong in our culture would not be fair. We may not understand his position if we have never walked in his shoes, but right and wrong can be judged. It would be safe to say that our values and morals based on our experiences, influences from society and family of origin. Our environment, nature and nurture plays a significant role in our value system. This issue is a two edged sword. The norm for a culture or subculture to behave in an immoral way may be acceptable in that environment, but it does not justify an immoral act. There are universal values such as murder. Just because a culture or subculture practices human sacrifice or cannibalism, it is still morally wrong. They may not realize it is wrong, based on their conscience. Ignorance of right and wrong does not justify the action. There may not be consequences in their culture to commit immoral acts but it does not mean there may not be consequences in an after life. If there is a higher power, they may stand accountable.
Conclusion: Cultural differences do not justify acts of violence against another human being because:
P: Inflicting pain on another individual does not justify the behavior just because it is a cultural practice.
P: Just because you do not know any better, does not make it right to violate another human
P: They would not like to be the recipient of the torturous acts if the immoral or torture was done against them.
P: Pain is pain is pain. Any living thing does not enjoy pain.
C: Therefore, it is correct to say that all moral values are relative to the culture they are found in (or therefore it is NOT correct to say…)
QUESTION #2: Is it a mark of ignorance to pass judgments on other cultures or to claim that one culture is better than another?
ANSWER : I do not believe it is a sign of ignorance to pass judgement on other immoral actions by other cultures. It may be ritualistic but it does not escape judgement. Here on earth or the after life. I believe we must remain true to our self and not compromise our value system to accommodate other cultures. It is okay to maintain a standard, universal standard of right and wrong, moral and immoral when it comes to violating another human or living thing. Our judgements are based on a standard whether from the Bible, Koran, Karma or whatever spiritual or human dignity that we believe in. Judgement is an opinion of right and wrong, however, does not necessarily mean we are imposing punishment based on our opinion. There may be graces or exceptions to the rule. As an example, a young girl murders her father is not morally, legally or spiritually acceptable. However, given the circumstances that he was raping her for years and she reacted in self defense.
C: Therefore it is NOT a mark of ignorance to pass because:
P: To compromise a moral value, universal standard is to water down and minimize inappropriate behavior
P: The frequency of committing immoral behavior will sear the conscience to recognize right from wrong.
P: They may commit an immoral act today and feel justified, however, how do we know if it will not torture their conscience tomorrow.
P: Maintaining a standard of right and wrong and judging immoral behavior is a mark of staying true to one's own self.
PART TWO
Page 64, 12b The missionary's action is justifiable based on her mission to reach, teach, educate a primitive tribe that their superstition of cutting off an offender's hand is unnecessary suffering of a human being. There may be other appropriate consequences without undue human suffering. Her teaching may help them to put them self in the shoes of the offender and help them to think about how they would feel if it were them. The missionaries mission is to bring a form of faith and alternative perspectives on their primitive culture. The missionary is there to teach that a loving God will provide and by trusting in a good God that loves them versus a god that rejoices in the torture of humans does not inspire people to love a mean god. The missionary is fulfilling her purpose by presenting alternatives to teach life changing values.
Conclusion: The missionary's actions are justifiable because:
P: A missionary's role is to reach people and bring peace and freedom to the primitive tribe
P: The missionary has a responsibility to follow her convictions and share the values of human life and how to avoid merciless torture.
P: If the primitive tribe never hears alternatives, how will they learn a more civil response to how they treat human beings
P: It gives the tribe the opportunity of choice once they hear an alternative way to respond
P: Given the opportunity and new way of thinking, they may see a more loving God or reason to believe there is a way to respond without human torture.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment