Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Blog Assignment #9

ASSIGNMENT PART ONE

In this section, we're going to return for a moment to Chapter 7, to the section that discusses errors that are common in the analysis of moral issues (p. 89). Briefly explain each of the following errors in your own words, as if you were explaining the concept to a friend who had never taken this class (consider who, what, when, where, why, how, when); and then give an example of each one, preferably from your own past experience.

Unwarranted Assumptions:
Unwarranted assumptions is when you jump to a conclusion before you know the details. You assume and read between the lines of things that may not be true.

JUDGMENT: The VW Service Department Was Overcharging me for Repairs to my car
P: The mechanics work on commission and therefore found more things to charge me for
P: The neighborhood mechanic only charged me $400 instead of $3500
P: The neighborhood mechanic said the other repairs were not necessary
CONCLUSION (Unwarranted Assumption): Dealerships are unfair and are dishonest

Oversimplification:
Oversimplification is when we minimize or omit important facts of a case or situation. As a result of oversimplifying, it does not give the full picture or can distort the outcome. When dealing with an embarrassing family matter or personal situation, it is often easy to oversimplify as a coping mechanism. Minimizing the facts.

Hasty Conclusions:
I am GUILTY! Hasty conclusions is when we jump to a judgement without having all the facts. Reacting instead of responding. The fear of a consequence can contribute to a quick judgment without fully understanding the situation or case. I like the example of separate self into two people. The first person is the idea producer and the second person is the idea evaluator. And the IF... THEN thought process. This helps you to consider all the criteria and consider the possible outcomes before jumping to a hasty conclusion.

JUDGMENT: My son will go to jail

P: He smelled of beer

P: He was going to drive

P: He had a beer with dinner

CONCLUSION (Hasty Conclusion): He will get a DUI if he drives

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO


1. What do we do in situations where there is more than a single obligation?

Try to fulfill both obligations if possible. Consider which one is most important. Make the best of both obligations and try to make up to the obligation we had to break in order to keep the other. Use the "IF....THEN" to evaluate the obligation.


2. How can we reconcile conflicting obligations?

Ask the "IF...THEN" question to think through the consequences and evaluate which one holds a higher priority. Try to resolve by managing both obligations and if not possible and one obligation must be broken, try to make it up. I try to be careful to not over commit or avoid having conflicting obligations. However, when faced with it, I evaluate carefully the situation and ask myself, what can I live with if I break this obligation or the other. I follow my heart, my conscience, my value system and then try to redeem my broken obligation in another way.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART THREE

1. In a nutshell, what is the most important thing, for you, that you learned from this assignment?

I learned that I have more obligations than I realized. There are many more conflicting obligations than I realized in my life. To use the IF.... THEN question, it helps me to evaluate the outcome of the obligations and decisions I have to make. I also learned to give greater consideration to the details of a case and to think of the impact and outcome before making a judgement.

2. How will you apply what you learned through this assignment to your everyday life?

LISTEN, LISTEN, LISTEN. Listen more before I speak. Consider all the details before I jump to a conclusion. Again, using the IF... THEN will really help me to think before I speak!

3. What grade do you believe your efforts regarding this assignment deserve? Justify your answer. This is a revised version. My first blog was way longer and even though I spent more time, I did not really understand. I had to revise to be more applicable to the questions. Therefore, because I went back and completed a second time, hopefully, this time with better answers, I earned the 25 points.

No comments:

Post a Comment