Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Blog Assignment #10

Ethical Decision Making Framework
Michele Kuntz
Thurs. South Campus
Blog Assignment #10

STEP ONE:
THE DETAILS OF THE CASE(1) Choose one inquiry, from inquiries 1 - 28 (pages 114 - 117). Indicate which inquiry you chose, and then briefly explain it in your own words:
#11 An eight year old boy, Tom gives an expensive birthday gift to a poor boy after his parents told him to take special care of it.

(2) Stakeholders: Name each person, group, organization, etc., that has a stake in this outcome.
Tom (the eight year old)
Poor Boy
Parents
Poor Boy’s Parents, Siblings

(3) Are the details given sufficient? Why or why not?
I do not believe the details were sufficient. There are many questions to make an ethical judgment. The scenario does not tell us the consequence, if there was any. The parents may have modeled giving to those less fortunate.

(4) What additional questions does this inquiry raise?
How much did the toy cost? Did Tom ask his parents if he could give it away? What did the parents mean by “taking special care of the toy?” Was special care not losing it, not breaking it? Is giving to less fortunate a value Tom’s parents encouraged? What was the outcome, were his parents proud of Tom’s action or upset?

STEP TWO: THE RELEVANT CRITERIA
1. Obligations (aka "duties"): Obligations of Friendship, because his poor friend did not have any toys. Obligation of Beneficence, because Tom did a random act of kindness toward his poor friend. Obligation to his Parents, to do what he was told to do or to ask permission “if” he could give his toy away.

2. Moral Ideals (aka "virtues"): Virtue of Loving Kindness: “Love your neighbor as yourself“, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you”
Virtue of Compassion: Tom was empathetic toward the poor boy and gave him the toy because he was staring at his new toy.
Virtue of Courage: Tom gave away his new toy that his parents said to take special care of regardless of the consequences of his parents being upset with him.Virtue of Gratitude: Tom may have been grateful for all the toys he already has and therefore was generous by giving this one away.Virtue of Beneficence: Tom did a random act of kindness by giving the poor boy his toy with no expectation of return.Conflicting ideals: --consider the relative importance of each; determine which ideal represents the greater good (or the lesser evil). By giving his toy away, he may get in trouble with his parents, however, by showing loving kindness, courage, and beneficence these ideals may be of greater importance to Tom. He may have to ask forgiveness from his parents, repent or even reparation if his parents asked his to pay for the toy out of his piggy bank. It could also be a conflict with temperance, if he did not restrain his desire to give regardless of his parents instruction to take good care of his new toy.

3. Consequences (aka "outcomes" or "results"):
1)Tom may suffer consequences with his parents for giving his toy away without asking permission.
2) Tom’s parents may view it that Tom was not grateful for the new toy.
3) Tom’s parents may be upset because it was an expensive toy and they used all their savings. 4) Tom’s parents may be very proud of him for his compassion, generosity, and sacrifice he made by giving his new toy away.
5) Tom may regret his impulsive decision and may not get another toy like this one.
6) Tom’s parents may be so proud of his action that they buy him another one just like it.

STEP THREE: POSSIBLE COURSES OF ACTION
Alternative #1: Tom could have called his parents and asked permission before he gave his toy away.
Alternative #2: Tom could have saved his money and purchased the poor boy a different toy at a different time.
Alternative #3: Tom could have given the boy some of his other toys instead of the new birthday present.

STEP FOUR:
THE MOST ETHICAL ACTION Examine the action taken or proposed and decide whether it achieves the greater good (the most widespread "respect for persons")...if it does not, choose one that will, from your alternatives. Where the choice of actions is such that no good can be achieved, choose the action that will result in the lesser evil.

Alternative #1 provides the greater good for all. Tom asking permission before giving his toy away would have been respecting his obligation to his parents. They could have said yes, and then there would be no bad consequences. Or if his parents responded with no, he could have saved his money and bought the little boy a toy. The book references three requirements which is referred to as the “principle of the double effect.” These three conditions are when the good consequences outweigh, can not be separated from or not intended the bad consequences. The reasoning is stated in the book,“Is it justifiable to perform an act that is not in itself evil but produces mixed consequences, some of them beneficial and others harmful?”(page 121)

SELF EVALUATION
1. In your own words, describe something new that you learned from this week’s assigned reading material and guidance.

The most significant thing I learned was to consider the details of a case, a situation, or dilemma before I form my moral or ethical conclusion. Think about the consequences and choose the better of two evils or achieve the greater good. It makes me think about the situation without reacting with an immediate conclusion or judgment. I have a choice on how I want to respond to an event or situation.

2. In your own words, describe in detail some insight you gained, about the material, from one of your classmates' blogs this week.

Blog posted by andeps-ethicsblog at andeps-ethicsblog1
1. In your own words, describe something new that you learned from this week’s assigned reading material and guidance.“The explanation of courage was meaningful to me. I guess I never really thought of it as having 3 dimensions. I was moved by the story about the little girl on the bus who befriended the other boy. I would not have thought about it being a conflict of ideals – I now realize that it was not exactly honest, but it was certainly the right thing to do.”
There were very few blogs posted to read. However, I also liked the example Paul referred to. It challenged my thinking, to think a little deeper about the case. I would value the ideal of Loving Kindness and Courage over Honesty. The conflict with honesty has an exception, when telling the truth would bring harm, damage, or hurt to the person we are being honest with. It takes courage to stand against peer pressure and be kind, compassionate, and empathetic to the unlovely.

3. Did you post a thoroughly completed post to your blog on time this week?
Yes, I completed the entire assignment and posted my blog on time this week.

4. Did you ALSO print this out, so you can bring it to class and earn total points? Yes, I printed this out and will bring it to class tomorrow! ON TIME!

5. Of 25 points total, my efforts this week deserve:
My effort on this assignment earned the 25 points because I have read, analyzed, considered the case in light of the guidelines between obligations, moral ideals, consequences and dilemmas. This assignment was helpful in gaining a better understanding of who, what, when, why, and how of analyzing ethical issues. I considered what I read before I answered the questions and I referred back to my book to make sure I responded with understanding. I got the most out of this assignment, maybe because it is finally sinking in. Thanks!

No comments:

Post a Comment