Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Blog Assignment #4

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART ONE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The Relationship between Law & Ethics

1. Paragraph: explain in your own words what the relationship is between laws and ethics.

Laws and ethics are not necessarily the same, however, they are interdependent upon each other. Laws are external guidelines, boundaries, or rules that govern our society and set by lawmakers who decide what is right or wrong legally. Ethics are the internal guidelines that define our morality. What is right or wrong, good or bad, and based on how an individual believes or what is socially acceptable. Both are judged by being right or wrong, however, laws can be enforced but ethics can not be enforced unless it violates the law. Laws have external consequences, whereas, ethics may or may not suffer internal consequences such as guilt or shame depending on the value system of the individual. Without ethics it is not possible to have laws. Ethics on the other hand is subjective to the circumstances and the lack thereof does not violate the laws of the land.

2. Paragraph & Link: Find one online resources related to this topic—not Wikipedia. Explain in a brief paragraph what you learned about this topic through the resource you found; include the link at the end of your paragraph.

It appears that the issue of law and ethics has been a topic of debate for sometime. One of the great debates occurred in 1958 at Harvard Law Review between H.L.A. Hart (an Oxford Professor) and Lon Fuller (Harvard Law School). Fuller's position was that “law was not a neutral concept, but that it already embodied an inner morality of its own". Hart stated, "nothing called law can be wicked or unjust". This historical debate is being celebrated almost fifty years later at New York University Law School and the NYU Law Review on February 1-2, 2009. Ethics, morality and the law overlap and influence each other. Without ethics, we would not have laws and without laws morality or the lack thereof would become non existent.
http://www.law.nyu.edu/conferences/hartfuller/index.htm

3. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not we need ethics, given that we already have laws.


Conclusion: (FOR) We need ethics, given that we already have laws.

Premises: We need ethics, given that we already have laws because:

(1) We need ethics to maintain a conscience and morality.

(2) We need ethics to consider others & maintain "The Golden Rule"

(3) We need ethics to uphold law, order, and safety in our society


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The Role of the Majority View

1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what a Majority View is.

The majority view is based on statistical results. The greatest number in a group that holds an opinion or view of what is right or wrong. The majority view may not have all the information to make an adequate judgement. Without given all the details of a situation, it would be difficult to trust the opinion of the majority's view, therefore, it may not be a trustworthy source. We must use critical thinking to consider the circumstances that may influence our thinking based on the known and the unknown.

2. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not the Majority View is a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.

Conclusion: (AGAINST) The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making

Premises: The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making because:

(1) The majority view may not have all the information to form a conclusion

(2) The majority view could falsely accuse or judge based on limited information

(3) The majority view can lead in the wrong direction


The Role of Feelings

1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what feelings are.

Feelings are subjective and can not be relied upon for determining morality or decisions. Feelings can include desires and or preferences and can change based on circumstances. If everyone acted upon their feelings, desires or preferences, we would live in a world without boundaries. Feelings are fickle and can lead us down the wrong path. I may have strong feelings to act in a certain manner to escape the pain of the circumstance I am facing. However, logic and common sense should be balanced with feelings. Many factors can influence feelings, surroundings, health, external and internal forces. Therefore, similar to the majority view, feelings require critical thinking skills to dissect.

2. Argument:
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not our feelings are a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.

Conclusion: (Against) Feelings are not a reliable basis for ethical decision making.

Premises: Feelings are not a basis for ethical decision making because:

(1) Feelings can change and therefore are not a reliable source for decision making.

(2) Feelings are based on emotion and are not logical about decision making

(3) Feelings are influenced by external factors and can be deceiving in decision making.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART THREE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ability to express yourself in your own words is essential in this class. Did you put everything in your own words this time?


Yes, I wrote from my heart and expressed myself in my own words.


What was easiest / hardest about this assignment?



The easiest part of this assignment was researching the relationship between ethics and law. I found it interesting and it made me aware of the dilemma in this debatable issue. The hardest part of this assignment for me is structuring the arguments. I think I am over thinking on how to word my premises. I understand the format but am not satisfied with what I have written. I may revisit my answers and revise before you grade this.

How will you apply what you learned through this assignment to your everyday life?

This assignment has influenced me in how I think about things. I tend to form my opinion quickly and this assignment has helped me to use critical thinking skills. To think outside the box and not be so quick to form my opinion. It also reinforces my value of being true to myself. When considering the majority view, be open minded, however, remain true to my values even if I stand alone. I will apply this to my decision making, to how I respond to my son, and to challenge my own thoughts and ideas.

How well do you think you did on this assignment? Explain.

I have done well on this assignment because I spent the time reading, pondering, and re-reading the assignment before I answered the questions. I did not just answer the questions but gave thoughtful consideration in everything that I wrote. I enjoyed the assignment and have a better understanding of moral relativism, ethics, law and religion. I found the chapter on majority views and feelings very interesting and enjoyed contemplating the inquiries at the end of each chapter.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Blog Assignment #3

1. Explain what “to give an argument” means in this book.

According to the book, to give an argument means to present why you believe or have an opinion by demonstrating, proving and defending how you have come to your belief. Reasons are supported by evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are defined as a way to evaluate and defend with supporting evidence an opinion, belief, or theory. Arguments are a testimony of your views with an attempt persuade and support with evidence how you have come to your conclusion.

What are the reasons Weston gives in support of his claim, “arguments are essential”?

Weston states that arguments are essential to determine which idea has a better platform and can be supported with evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are a way to illustrate or prove my position and how I have supported my belief, opinion, theory. How can I be convincing to present my ideas without knowing how I have arrived at my opinion? There must be reasons to support my conclusions. By supporting my reasons and conclusions in a clear and concise format, it will make my presentation more convincing and will help others to form a conclusion the same way I have formed my conclusion.


3. Explain why many students tend to “write an essay, but not an argument”.


Weston explains the reason students write an essay but not an argument is because they do not understand how to support their belief or views on an issue. In order to write an argumentative essay, you must not only state your reasons for your view but the evidence to support your conclusion. One way Weston suggests preparing for an argumentative essay is to evaluate both sides. By evaluating both sides, you are more prepared to defend your conclusions and support how you have formed your opinion and views.

4. Construct two short arguments (one "for" and one "against") as modeled in the Week 3 Assignment section in Blackboard. Put each one in "elements form".

Argument AGAINST an Adoptee Locating Birth Parent(s)

Arguable issue: Whether or not an Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s)
Conclusion: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s).

Premises: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s) because:

1) Doing so will violate the privacy of the birth parent(s) and their new family

2) Doing so will be a disappointment and will hurt the adoptee emotionally

3) Doing so will hurt their adopted family

Argument FOR an Adoptee to locate Birth Parent(s)

Conclusion: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s)

Premises: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s) because:

1) Doing so will help satisfy the birth parent(s) guilt

2) Doing so will help the adoptee know their medical history and gain understanding why they were placed for adoption.

3) Doing so will open the door to have a relationship with their birth parent(s) and siblings

5. Review the seven rules in chapter one. Briefly discuss how your argument demonstrates that each rule was applied, in the construction of your arguments above.

1) Distinguish Premises and Conclusion. The purpose of my argument is to support the benefits of finding your birth parents. 2) Present your ideas in a natural order. I started out with my conclusion and then supported my conclusion with my premises. Using my own personal experience as well as the opinions of the opposing side. 3) Start from reliable premises. I used premises from my own experience and from the experience of other adoptees finding their birth parents. 4) Be concrete and concise. I have avoided abstract, vague and general terms. I tried to keep it simple and to the point. 5) Avoid loaded language. I have tried to be objective on both sides in my wording. I have not used words that would discriminate toward either side even though I have a strong opinion for or against. Which one do you think it is? 6) Use consistent terms. I have tried to stay with the effects on the birth parents, the adoptee and the adopted family. 7) Stick to one meaning for each term. I have stayed with one meaning for each term. I have avoided the classical fallacy of equivocation.

6. Review the three rules in the appendix named, “Definitions”. In your own words, discuss how you took these rules into consideration as you constructed your arguments.

First clearly identify the meaning of your words. Using a dictionary can not be your only source to define and clearly state your terms. Avoid vague, mixed message words and do not minimize the context to the point of losing the meaning . Be as specific as possible so that the words are understandable and not easily misconstrued. Make sure both parties are discussing the same thing. Defining the word alone does not defend the argument. When the understanding of term is contested, there are three steps to clarify. 1) Include all things that fit, 2) exclude all things that do not fit, and 3) draw a line somewhere in between and explain why.

I reviewed the appendix of definitions before I constructed my arguments. I tried to be as clear and concise to state my terms. I tried to listen to how others would hear it. I tried to differentiate between an adopted vs. birth family.

7. Good posts demonstrate:
Sincere reflection, effort, and analysis
Answers that are substantial (at least one large paragraph each)
Consistent mention, citation, and integration of the assigned readings. How many points do you honestly feel your post this week deserves? Justify your answer.

If points are earned on effort, I earned 25. However, I am not sure I completely understand everything. I guess that is why they call it learning! I definitely read, reflected and answered the questions to the best of my ability in my own words. In addition to reading the material, I referred back to the books as I was writing. I kept notes of everything I read to review and refresh and hopefully gain a greater understanding to master the material. And last but not least, I got it posted before 11:59!

Blog Assignment #2

1. Were the questions on the Moral Sense Test difficult to answer (psychologically, emotionally, conceptually, technically, etc.)? Why or why not? Do you think your responses to the Moral Sense Test questions were consistent? Does this matter?


The questions were not difficult to answer, however, I had to resist my instinctive answer and contemplate what I might do if I were in a similar situation. My first response would be to avoid hurting anyone, even if the intention was to help someone else. As I carefully thought about the situation, I had additional questions before I could respond with a definitive answer. Without all the details available, I responded with my first impression. I can see that under certain circumstances I could have responded differently to each situation. In all of the scenarios, I believed there were alternative options that could potentially help one scenario without hurting someone in the process. Psychologically and emotionally the moral decision for me would be, to not intentionally hurt someone for any reason. Technically, there could be a situation where it would be the right or moral response to inflict harm on one person to save hundreds. An example of this would be the decision that was made on 911 when the passengers overtook the terrorists forcing a crash and their lives to avoid killing thousands. The test questions were overall consistent with the exception of one. The hide and seek game was a competition to win. Dropping a branch, (depending on how big of a branch) would be morally acceptable "IF" it would not injure the girl in the bush.


2. Should people always follow the law? Why or why not? When might one be justified in NOT following the law? Give examples.

My opinion about following the law is very rigid. "Follow the laws of the land". I believe the laws are set to protect us all. Laws are boundaries to serve and protect everyone. I may not always agree with the law but I will follow the law to the best of my ability. There are times that laws are broken without the intent to break the law. So there is the exclusion to my opinion based on intent. They say, ignorance of the law does not excuse the consequences, however, if you know it is wrong and you do it anyway, then I feel differently. In addition, I believe you reap what you sow. You may get away with not following the law, but eventually you will get caught. You can only run so many red lights without getting caught. Then again, it could just be my paranoid, guilt driven conscious. :) However, there would be situations that I could justify breaking the law. I can assume I would shoot someone if they were a threat to myself or my family. Then again, if I were in the situation, I am not sure what my instinct would do. Unless I actually experience it first hand, I may not be able to shoot someone. Another example of not following the law would be if I were abducted and the car jacker has a gun pointed at my head and told me to keep driving. I could see myself intentionally colliding with another vehicle to draw attention and hopefully escape from the bad guy! Another example would be if I were driving someone to the hospital with a life threatening condition. I would speed, run red lights and do whatever I could to get the passenger help. However, I would do my best to avoid hurting someone else in the process.

3. In your own words, explain what "social convention" means. Give examples.

Social convention is a spoken, unspoken, or socially acceptable behavior that the majority or society lives by. An example of a social convention could be a man giving up his seat for a woman. Another example would be to open the door for a woman or a handicapped person. A third example would be to not begin eating until everyone has been served. These would be considered "good manners". However, there are moral, religious, ethical, cultural and socially acceptable behaviors that may be different for different environments.

4. Should people always follow the conventions of their society? Why or why not? Give examples.

"Should" is an interesting word. Whether they should or should not could be different for different people. This could be influenced by age, culture, upbringing, etc. It would be nice if most followed the conventions of their society, however, there may be factors why a person may not follow social conventions. An example would be how we greet people. Growing up in an Italian family, it was normal to hug and kiss both sides of your face. For some, this type of greeting would be invasive and overstepping an individuals boundary. Social conventions can be a result of the environment you are raised in. Nature vs. Nurture creates an interesting concept. I was adopted and have learned behaviors (Nurture) and instinctive behaviors (Nature) that reflect both my birth family and my adopted family. I read a statistic, (that I can not quote from where) that there are just as many PhD that raised drug addicts as there are drug addicts that raised PhD. Therefore, do others follow social conventions or is their behavior an innate response.

5. Should people always follow their own principles? Why or why not? Give examples.

Yes, I do believe you should follow your convictions, principles, and values that you have defined for yourself. "To thine own self be true". However, principles and values can change or broaden as a result of life experiences. For example, after surviving a near death experience I thought, "if I am going to die, why not have fun today"? The first mistake was the "if". It is not if but when. However, when I became a mother, I no longer took risks that could leave my child motherless. So after my son's birth, I quit jumping off the Dames Point Bridge for fun. :) Just kidding about the bridge part. One last thought, if I do not follow my own principles, I get to live with the consequences of not being true to myself. I do what I believe is the right thing to do, however, I am not so rigid that I am not open to feedback for consideration. Even if they do say, you can not teach old dogs, new tricks.

6. Explain in your own words the difference between socially acceptable, legally acceptable, and morally acceptable.

Socially acceptable would be what the majority of society considers to be normal and acceptable behavior such as wearing a bikini to school! It may cause a few raised brows or strained necks! This would also depend on the society, culture, or environment you are in. What is socially acceptable to one may be totally inappropriate to another.

Legally acceptable would be anything within the statutes. An example would be regarding the concealed weapon's permit. You may only carry a loaded gun on your person if you obtain your concealed weapon's permit. There are certain places that you are not able to carry a gun, such as school or the post office. If you ever have to use your gun, you can not shoot to kill. That is not legally acceptable. You are only able to shoot to stop someone from committing a crime against you or your family. Can you tell I just took my concealed weapon's permit class?

Morally acceptable is a code of ethics or moral values that a society, environment, culture, religion or group lives by. It depends on the moral standards and circumstances of your environment. I would describe morally acceptable by biblical principles, such as the ten commandments. Thou shalt not commit adultery. However, it also says if you lust in your heart, you have committed adultery. Therefore, morally acceptable is an individual value system. There are exceptions to morally acceptable behavior. Some situations may provoke a response that would be deemed morally unacceptable, however, necessary to protect another individual from being hurt. I believe our conscious is a moral guide. If the conscious is ignored long enough, it will allow you to violate your own moral code. An example would be if you were to put a hot iron on your arm, it would burn the first time. However, if you continue with the same action, eventually scar tissue would form and you will not feel the pain when you put the hot iron on the same spot. Moral of the story, don't iron your clothes when you are wearing them.

7. Out of 25 points, how many points do you feel your work on this assignment deserves? Justify your answer.

I believe I deserve the 25 points for a couple. The number one reason, I have had to put in several hours trying to master this blog thing! I hate to admit that this may be my first generational disconnect! You could have been speaking a foreign language to me, it was that confusing to me. However, with hours and hours of persistence, I think I got it. I still have a way to go, but I am on my way. "It is not the destination but the journey" Fun! The second reason is because I have read my books and gave careful thought and consideration to each and every question. Now I will try to publish this BLOG! Hope it arrives safely!

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Blog Assignment #1

1. How would you have explained the meaning of the term "ethics", before taking this class?

The meaning of the term "ethics" is a character attribute imparted, adopted, or develped. When I think of ethics or an ethical person or decision, there are many descriptive words that come to mind. Ethics are the core values and belief system we live by and can be measured differently by different people, cultures or age groups. When I think of ethics, I think of integrity, honesty, doing the right thing, values, and the code of ethics we live our life by. Our own measuring stick of right and wrong.


2. What are some of your deepest held values?
My deepest held values are my faith in God, honesty, integrity, pure hearted, honesty and doing the right thing even when it hurts. Being kind, genuine, sincere, and caring about the needs of others less fortunate than myself. I value family, friends, and relationships. The most treasured value is the ability to be true to one's own self. To live life to the fullest without compromising the core values that make you who you are!


3. What are some main principles you try to live your life by?

I try to live a balanced life which is often a struggle for me as a type A perfectionist! For the most part, I try to live one day at a time and focus on what I am grateful for. I find when I live "Just for Today", I have greater peace and joy in my life. When I worry about tomorrow, it steals the joy I have for today. Another principle I try to live by is to take time to pray and meditate daily. This helps me to keep life in perspective. However, my favorite principle that I try to live by is to accept the things I can not change, change the things I can, and ask for wisdom to know the difference. Some days I do great at living by the principles I cherish in my life. However, none of us will escape this life without pain, disappointment or difficulty. So I try to accept life on life's terms, trusting that I am exactly where I need to be to learn something or grow through the experience, even when it is painful or difficult. What keeps me sane is to remember that this too shall pass and change is only hard if you resist it. So full circle, I am back to trying to work at living one day at a time, grateful for all the blessings and seeking peace, contentment and acceptance. Like they say, "It is not the destination, it is the journey".


4. What moral qualities do you look for in others?

The moral qualities I look for in others is trustworthiness, honesty, and positive outlook even in the midst of difficulty. I admire those that have the ability to stand strong in the midst of adversity. I think it says alot about a person that has the ability to get their eyes off their own struggles and find room in their heart to help others. I love to associate with individuals that do the right thing regardless of the cost to themself. In addition, I respect those that choose to look at the glass half full and not half empty.


5. How were your values and principles developed?

There are many contributing factors that have developed my values and principles that I live by, strive for, and will continue to grow in day by day. My family of origin played a big part in my value system, however, the greater impact and changes came through overcoming great difficulties. At the age of 19 I faced a life threatening illness that had a huge impact on forming my value system. The most difficult things in my life seem to have had the greatest impact in the development of my character. That is the greatest beauty of growing older. You have the advantage of looking back at what felt like a difficult time, however, looking back through the years, I can see the good that came out of it. Difficulties can either refine you and make you better or bitter. What does not kill you makes you better. We have two choices on how we perceive circumstances and how we reflect on our life. I choose to find the good and use the circumstance to learn about myself and grow from the experience. Don't get me wrong, I don't like pain. But pain is an inevitable part of living. Learning to accept life on life's terms is one of the greatest challenges in life and yet may be one of the most satisfying places to be.


6. How have your values and principles changed throughout your life so far?

My values and principles continue to change as I experience life. Some of the things I value have become stronger and more concrete in my life. When I was younger, I would compromise my values to be accepted by others or to fit in. However, the more I compromised my values, the unhappier I would be. So through the years, I have learned to stand strong for what I believe and value even if I stand alone. To be true to myself brings a greater joy and satisfaction than to try to please others. In other cases, I have become more open to the opinions of others, because that may be what is right for them. I have grown in this area by allowing others to be true to their own self. What is right for me may not be right for them and visa versa. So I feel I will continue to grow, evaluate, and redefine my values and principles depending on the stage of life I am in. Some values will become stronger and others may change based on what life brings my way. I try to stay open minded, remembering that so much is based on perspective. My values and principles have been formed as a result of every life experience, the environment and many other factors. Therefore, how can we judge the man that walks with a hunched back? For all we know, he may have tacks in his shoes.


7. Out of 25 points, how many points do you feel your work on this assignment deserves? Justify your a nswer.

I believe I have earned the 25 points on this assignment because I was diligent in really giving thought about each question. I did not just answer the question without contemplating the depth of my innermost thoughts. In addition, I was persistent to finally set up my blog and post to it, a method as complicated and confusing as a foreign language. Blogging, posting, is brand new to me and I did not give up until I got it. Hooray! One down and many more to go! :) And I thoroughly enjoyed the activity.