ASSIGNMENT PART ONE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Relationship between Law & Ethics
1. Paragraph: explain in your own words what the relationship is between laws and ethics.
Laws and ethics are not necessarily the same, however, they are interdependent upon each other. Laws are external guidelines, boundaries, or rules that govern our society and set by lawmakers who decide what is right or wrong legally. Ethics are the internal guidelines that define our morality. What is right or wrong, good or bad, and based on how an individual believes or what is socially acceptable. Both are judged by being right or wrong, however, laws can be enforced but ethics can not be enforced unless it violates the law. Laws have external consequences, whereas, ethics may or may not suffer internal consequences such as guilt or shame depending on the value system of the individual. Without ethics it is not possible to have laws. Ethics on the other hand is subjective to the circumstances and the lack thereof does not violate the laws of the land.
2. Paragraph & Link: Find one online resources related to this topic—not Wikipedia. Explain in a brief paragraph what you learned about this topic through the resource you found; include the link at the end of your paragraph.
It appears that the issue of law and ethics has been a topic of debate for sometime. One of the great debates occurred in 1958 at Harvard Law Review between H.L.A. Hart (an Oxford Professor) and Lon Fuller (Harvard Law School). Fuller's position was that “law was not a neutral concept, but that it already embodied an inner morality of its own". Hart stated, "nothing called law can be wicked or unjust". This historical debate is being celebrated almost fifty years later at New York University Law School and the NYU Law Review on February 1-2, 2009. Ethics, morality and the law overlap and influence each other. Without ethics, we would not have laws and without laws morality or the lack thereof would become non existent.
http://www.law.nyu.edu/conferences/hartfuller/index.htm
3. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not we need ethics, given that we already have laws.
Conclusion: (FOR) We need ethics, given that we already have laws.
Premises: We need ethics, given that we already have laws because:
(1) We need ethics to maintain a conscience and morality.
(2) We need ethics to consider others & maintain "The Golden Rule"
(3) We need ethics to uphold law, order, and safety in our society
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Role of the Majority View
1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what a Majority View is.
The majority view is based on statistical results. The greatest number in a group that holds an opinion or view of what is right or wrong. The majority view may not have all the information to make an adequate judgement. Without given all the details of a situation, it would be difficult to trust the opinion of the majority's view, therefore, it may not be a trustworthy source. We must use critical thinking to consider the circumstances that may influence our thinking based on the known and the unknown.
2. Argument
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not the Majority View is a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.
Conclusion: (AGAINST) The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making
Premises: The Majority View is not a reliable basis for ethical decision-making because:
(1) The majority view may not have all the information to form a conclusion
(2) The majority view could falsely accuse or judge based on limited information
(3) The majority view can lead in the wrong direction
The Role of Feelings
1. Paragraph: Explain in your own words what feelings are.
Feelings are subjective and can not be relied upon for determining morality or decisions. Feelings can include desires and or preferences and can change based on circumstances. If everyone acted upon their feelings, desires or preferences, we would live in a world without boundaries. Feelings are fickle and can lead us down the wrong path. I may have strong feelings to act in a certain manner to escape the pain of the circumstance I am facing. However, logic and common sense should be balanced with feelings. Many factors can influence feelings, surroundings, health, external and internal forces. Therefore, similar to the majority view, feelings require critical thinking skills to dissect.
2. Argument:
Arguable Issue: The arguable issue is whether or not our feelings are a reliable basis for ethical decision-making.
Conclusion: (Against) Feelings are not a reliable basis for ethical decision making.
Premises: Feelings are not a basis for ethical decision making because:
(1) Feelings can change and therefore are not a reliable source for decision making.
(2) Feelings are based on emotion and are not logical about decision making
(3) Feelings are influenced by external factors and can be deceiving in decision making.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASSIGNMENT PART THREE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ability to express yourself in your own words is essential in this class. Did you put everything in your own words this time?
Yes, I wrote from my heart and expressed myself in my own words.
What was easiest / hardest about this assignment?
The easiest part of this assignment was researching the relationship between ethics and law. I found it interesting and it made me aware of the dilemma in this debatable issue. The hardest part of this assignment for me is structuring the arguments. I think I am over thinking on how to word my premises. I understand the format but am not satisfied with what I have written. I may revisit my answers and revise before you grade this.
How will you apply what you learned through this assignment to your everyday life?This assignment has influenced me in how I think about things. I tend to form my opinion quickly and this assignment has helped me to use critical thinking skills. To think outside the box and not be so quick to form my opinion. It also reinforces my value of being true to myself. When considering the majority view, be open minded, however, remain true to my values even if I stand alone. I will apply this to my decision making, to how I respond to my son, and to challenge my own thoughts and ideas.
How well do you think you did on this assignment? Explain.I have done well on this assignment because I spent the time reading, pondering, and re-reading the assignment before I answered the questions. I did not just answer the questions but gave thoughtful consideration in everything that I wrote. I enjoyed the assignment and have a better understanding of moral relativism, ethics, law and religion. I found the chapter on majority views and feelings very interesting and enjoyed contemplating the inquiries at the end of each chapter.