According to the book, to give an argument means to present why you believe or have an opinion by demonstrating, proving and defending how you have come to your belief. Reasons are supported by evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are defined as a way to evaluate and defend with supporting evidence an opinion, belief, or theory. Arguments are a testimony of your views with an attempt persuade and support with evidence how you have come to your conclusion.
What are the reasons Weston gives in support of his claim, “arguments are essential”?
Weston states that arguments are essential to determine which idea has a better platform and can be supported with evidence to reach a conclusion. Arguments are a way to illustrate or prove my position and how I have supported my belief, opinion, theory. How can I be convincing to present my ideas without knowing how I have arrived at my opinion? There must be reasons to support my conclusions. By supporting my reasons and conclusions in a clear and concise format, it will make my presentation more convincing and will help others to form a conclusion the same way I have formed my conclusion.
3. Explain why many students tend to “write an essay, but not an argument”.
Weston explains the reason students write an essay but not an argument is because they do not understand how to support their belief or views on an issue. In order to write an argumentative essay, you must not only state your reasons for your view but the evidence to support your conclusion. One way Weston suggests preparing for an argumentative essay is to evaluate both sides. By evaluating both sides, you are more prepared to defend your conclusions and support how you have formed your opinion and views.
4. Construct two short arguments (one "for" and one "against") as modeled in the Week 3 Assignment section in Blackboard. Put each one in "elements form".
Argument AGAINST an Adoptee Locating Birth Parent(s)
Arguable issue: Whether or not an Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s)
Conclusion: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s).
Premises: An Adoptee should not locate birth parent(s) because:
1) Doing so will violate the privacy of the birth parent(s) and their new family
2) Doing so will be a disappointment and will hurt the adoptee emotionally
3) Doing so will hurt their adopted family
Argument FOR an Adoptee to locate Birth Parent(s)
Conclusion: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s)
Premises: An Adoptee should locate birth parent(s) because:
1) Doing so will help satisfy the birth parent(s) guilt
2) Doing so will help the adoptee know their medical history and gain understanding why they were placed for adoption.
3) Doing so will open the door to have a relationship with their birth parent(s) and siblings
5. Review the seven rules in chapter one. Briefly discuss how your argument demonstrates that each rule was applied, in the construction of your arguments above.
1) Distinguish Premises and Conclusion. The purpose of my argument is to support the benefits of finding your birth parents. 2) Present your ideas in a natural order. I started out with my conclusion and then supported my conclusion with my premises. Using my own personal experience as well as the opinions of the opposing side. 3) Start from reliable premises. I used premises from my own experience and from the experience of other adoptees finding their birth parents. 4) Be concrete and concise. I have avoided abstract, vague and general terms. I tried to keep it simple and to the point. 5) Avoid loaded language. I have tried to be objective on both sides in my wording. I have not used words that would discriminate toward either side even though I have a strong opinion for or against. Which one do you think it is? 6) Use consistent terms. I have tried to stay with the effects on the birth parents, the adoptee and the adopted family. 7) Stick to one meaning for each term. I have stayed with one meaning for each term. I have avoided the classical fallacy of equivocation.
6. Review the three rules in the appendix named, “Definitions”. In your own words, discuss how you took these rules into consideration as you constructed your arguments.First clearly identify the meaning of your words. Using a dictionary can not be your only source to define and clearly state your terms. Avoid vague, mixed message words and do not minimize the context to the point of losing the meaning . Be as specific as possible so that the words are understandable and not easily misconstrued. Make sure both parties are discussing the same thing. Defining the word alone does not defend the argument. When the understanding of term is contested, there are three steps to clarify. 1) Include all things that fit, 2) exclude all things that do not fit, and 3) draw a line somewhere in between and explain why.
I reviewed the appendix of definitions before I constructed my arguments. I tried to be as clear and concise to state my terms. I tried to listen to how others would hear it. I tried to differentiate between an adopted vs. birth family.
7. Good posts demonstrate:
Sincere reflection, effort, and analysis
Answers that are substantial (at least one large paragraph each)
Consistent mention, citation, and integration of the assigned readings. How many points do you honestly feel your post this week deserves? Justify your answer.
If points are earned on effort, I earned 25. However, I am not sure I completely understand everything. I guess that is why they call it learning! I definitely read, reflected and answered the questions to the best of my ability in my own words. In addition to reading the material, I referred back to the books as I was writing. I kept notes of everything I read to review and refresh and hopefully gain a greater understanding to master the material. And last but not least, I got it posted before 11:59!
M-
ReplyDeleteI'm so proud of you, you're catching on to this blog business quick! And your posts are so thorough; thank you. I liked the arguable issue you considered; I'm adopted, so it was especially interesting for me to read these. Nice work all around! :) KJP
Thank you. I just found your comment! Too fun. I am really enjoying your class and I especially appreciate your patience and help you have given me! I have a fun story about meeting my birth mom and 2 sisters and a far out wild story about my birth father. I will share it with you sometime.
ReplyDelete