The questions were not difficult to answer, however, I had to resist my instinctive answer and contemplate what I might do if I were in a similar situation. My first response would be to avoid hurting anyone, even if the intention was to help someone else. As I carefully thought about the situation, I had additional questions before I could respond with a definitive answer. Without all the details available, I responded with my first impression. I can see that under certain circumstances I could have responded differently to each situation. In all of the scenarios, I believed there were alternative options that could potentially help one scenario without hurting someone in the process. Psychologically and emotionally the moral decision for me would be, to not intentionally hurt someone for any reason. Technically, there could be a situation where it would be the right or moral response to inflict harm on one person to save hundreds. An example of this would be the decision that was made on 911 when the passengers overtook the terrorists forcing a crash and their lives to avoid killing thousands. The test questions were overall consistent with the exception of one. The hide and seek game was a competition to win. Dropping a branch, (depending on how big of a branch) would be morally acceptable "IF" it would not injure the girl in the bush.
2. Should people always follow the law? Why or why not? When might one be justified in NOT following the law? Give examples.
My opinion about following the law is very rigid. "Follow the laws of the land". I believe the laws are set to protect us all. Laws are boundaries to serve and protect everyone. I may not always agree with the law but I will follow the law to the best of my ability. There are times that laws are broken without the intent to break the law. So there is the exclusion to my opinion based on intent. They say, ignorance of the law does not excuse the consequences, however, if you know it is wrong and you do it anyway, then I feel differently. In addition, I believe you reap what you sow. You may get away with not following the law, but eventually you will get caught. You can only run so many red lights without getting caught. Then again, it could just be my paranoid, guilt driven conscious. :) However, there would be situations that I could justify breaking the law. I can assume I would shoot someone if they were a threat to myself or my family. Then again, if I were in the situation, I am not sure what my instinct would do. Unless I actually experience it first hand, I may not be able to shoot someone. Another example of not following the law would be if I were abducted and the car jacker has a gun pointed at my head and told me to keep driving. I could see myself intentionally colliding with another vehicle to draw attention and hopefully escape from the bad guy! Another example would be if I were driving someone to the hospital with a life threatening condition. I would speed, run red lights and do whatever I could to get the passenger help. However, I would do my best to avoid hurting someone else in the process.
3. In your own words, explain what "social convention" means. Give examples.
Social convention is a spoken, unspoken, or socially acceptable behavior that the majority or society lives by. An example of a social convention could be a man giving up his seat for a woman. Another example would be to open the door for a woman or a handicapped person. A third example would be to not begin eating until everyone has been served. These would be considered "good manners". However, there are moral, religious, ethical, cultural and socially acceptable behaviors that may be different for different environments.
4. Should people always follow the conventions of their society? Why or why not? Give examples.
"Should" is an interesting word. Whether they should or should not could be different for different people. This could be influenced by age, culture, upbringing, etc. It would be nice if most followed the conventions of their society, however, there may be factors why a person may not follow social conventions. An example would be how we greet people. Growing up in an Italian family, it was normal to hug and kiss both sides of your face. For some, this type of greeting would be invasive and overstepping an individuals boundary. Social conventions can be a result of the environment you are raised in. Nature vs. Nurture creates an interesting concept. I was adopted and have learned behaviors (Nurture) and instinctive behaviors (Nature) that reflect both my birth family and my adopted family. I read a statistic, (that I can not quote from where) that there are just as many PhD that raised drug addicts as there are drug addicts that raised PhD. Therefore, do others follow social conventions or is their behavior an innate response.
5. Should people always follow their own principles? Why or why not? Give examples.
Yes, I do believe you should follow your convictions, principles, and values that you have defined for yourself. "To thine own self be true". However, principles and values can change or broaden as a result of life experiences. For example, after surviving a near death experience I thought, "if I am going to die, why not have fun today"? The first mistake was the "if". It is not if but when. However, when I became a mother, I no longer took risks that could leave my child motherless. So after my son's birth, I quit jumping off the Dames Point Bridge for fun. :) Just kidding about the bridge part. One last thought, if I do not follow my own principles, I get to live with the consequences of not being true to myself. I do what I believe is the right thing to do, however, I am not so rigid that I am not open to feedback for consideration. Even if they do say, you can not teach old dogs, new tricks.
6. Explain in your own words the difference between socially acceptable, legally acceptable, and morally acceptable.
Socially acceptable would be what the majority of society considers to be normal and acceptable behavior such as wearing a bikini to school! It may cause a few raised brows or strained necks! This would also depend on the society, culture, or environment you are in. What is socially acceptable to one may be totally inappropriate to another.
Legally acceptable would be anything within the statutes. An example would be regarding the concealed weapon's permit. You may only carry a loaded gun on your person if you obtain your concealed weapon's permit. There are certain places that you are not able to carry a gun, such as school or the post office. If you ever have to use your gun, you can not shoot to kill. That is not legally acceptable. You are only able to shoot to stop someone from committing a crime against you or your family. Can you tell I just took my concealed weapon's permit class?
Morally acceptable is a code of ethics or moral values that a society, environment, culture, religion or group lives by. It depends on the moral standards and circumstances of your environment. I would describe morally acceptable by biblical principles, such as the ten commandments. Thou shalt not commit adultery. However, it also says if you lust in your heart, you have committed adultery. Therefore, morally acceptable is an individual value system. There are exceptions to morally acceptable behavior. Some situations may provoke a response that would be deemed morally unacceptable, however, necessary to protect another individual from being hurt. I believe our conscious is a moral guide. If the conscious is ignored long enough, it will allow you to violate your own moral code. An example would be if you were to put a hot iron on your arm, it would burn the first time. However, if you continue with the same action, eventually scar tissue would form and you will not feel the pain when you put the hot iron on the same spot. Moral of the story, don't iron your clothes when you are wearing them.
7. Out of 25 points, how many points do you feel your work on this assignment deserves? Justify your answer.
I believe I deserve the 25 points for a couple. The number one reason, I have had to put in several hours trying to master this blog thing! I hate to admit that this may be my first generational disconnect! You could have been speaking a foreign language to me, it was that confusing to me. However, with hours and hours of persistence, I think I got it. I still have a way to go, but I am on my way. "It is not the destination but the journey" Fun! The second reason is because I have read my books and gave careful thought and consideration to each and every question. Now I will try to publish this BLOG! Hope it arrives safely!
No comments:
Post a Comment